The improvement of an employee with permanent disability does not always mean they can recover their job. We analyze when there is a true right to reinstatement and when only a preference to fill a future vacancy.


Few employment situations generate as much uncertainty as that of an employee who, after some time receiving a permanent disability benefit, is informed by Social Security that their health condition has improved enough to review or revoke that declaration. Suddenly, that person becomes fit to work again. The question is inevitable: do they have the right to return to their position in the company? The answer, like almost everything in law, is “it depends,” and it depends, above all, on one question: whether their contract was suspended with job reservation under article 48.2 of the Workers’ Statute or if, on the contrary, it ended due to the declaration of permanent disability. This post explains the difference.

All permanent disability is subject to review

It is worth starting with an idea that is often overlooked: the declaration of permanent disability is not definitive.  Article 200 of the Revised Text of the General Social Security Law allows reviewing the recognized degree, whether due to worsening, improvement, or diagnostic error, as long as the beneficiary has not reached retirement age. This possibility exists regardless of the degree: total permanent disability, absolute permanent disability and severe disability can all be reviewed and, where appropriate, revoked if the employee recovers their work capacity.

However, the fact that every permanent disability is reviewable does not mean that in all cases the employee has the right to have the company keep their position in the meantime. The review is a Social Security matter; job reservation is a labor matter, and only exists in the specific case regulated by article 48.2 of the Workers’ Statute.

Suspension with job reservation

As a general rule, the declaration of permanent total, absolute, or severe disability is grounds for termination of the employment contract according to article 49.1.n) of the Workers’ Statute “when it is not possible to make reasonable adjustments because it constitutes an excessive burden for the company, when there is no vacant and available job position consistent with the professional profile and compatible with the new situation of the employee, or when, if such possibility exists, the employee rejects the duly proposed job change”. Previous posts explain that permanent disability no longer automatically terminates the employment contract and that the company does not always have to adapt the job position in the event of permanent disability.30

Article 48.2 regulates a different case: when, after temporary disability, the employee is declared to be in a situation of total, absolute, or severe permanent disability and, in the opinion of the evaluation body, their situation is likely to be subject to improvement review that allows their return to the job, the contract is not terminated, but the suspension of the employment relationship remains, with the position reserved, for a period of two years from the date of the resolution declaring the permanent disability.

The key, therefore, lies in the incapacity resolution itself. For there to be a job reservation, it is not enough for the incapacity to be, in abstract, reviewable (which it always is), but the evaluation team must have expressly assessed that an improvement is foreseeable allowing the employee to return to their position within two years. If the resolution does not contain that provision, the contract is terminated without any reservation, even if the incapacity is later reviewed for improvement.

When this situation occurs, the consequences are clear. During those two years the contract is suspended: there is no obligation to work or pay, but the bond remains active and the company must keep the employee’s position. If within that period the disability is reviewed for improvement and the employee regains their capacity, they have the right to return to their position, and the company cannot refuse by claiming it has filled or eliminated it. If, on the other hand, two years pass without the review, the reservation lapses and the employment relationship can be considered terminated.

When the contract was terminated: the preferential right of re-entry under Royal Decree 1451/1983

The situation is very different when the contract was terminated due to the declaration of permanent disability, either because the resolution did not provide for an improvement or because the two years of reservation passed without review. To understand what rights the employee retains then, one must go back to Law 13/1982, of April 7, on the social integration of the disabled (known by its Spanish acronym, LISMI), a pioneering regulation at the time that laid the foundations for the labor protection of people with disabilities in Spain. Although this law was formally repealed by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2013, of November 29, which approved the Revised Text of the General Law on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and their Social Inclusion, its spirit survives in the regulatory framework issued in its development.

The key piece is Royal Decree 1451/1983, of May 11, issued in compliance with the provisions of article 2.1 of Law 13/1982, which regulates the so-called “selective employment” and measures to promote the employment of employees with disabilities. This regulation remains in force and establishes the applicable rules when an employee who left the company due to permanent disability subsequently has that declaration reviewed or revoked.

In this scenario, there is no job reservation. The employee cannot demand their chair back, because that chair may be legitimately occupied by someone else or may have been eliminated. But, and this is the fundamental nuance, that does not mean they lose all ties with the company.

What the regulation recognizes is a preferential right to rejoin the last company where they worked, at the first vacancy that occurs in their professional group or category. It is a conditional right, because it depends on whether a vacancy actually exists or is created, but it is a real and enforceable right.

What exactly does “preferential right” mean?

It is worth focusing on this expression because it is not a mere empty gesture by the legislator. “Preferential right” means that when a vacancy arises in the company corresponding to the employee’s professional group or category, the employee has priority to fill it over external candidates. The company cannot publish a job offer, hire a third party, or artificially eliminate the position while there is an employee with a preferential right of re-entry pending reinstatement.

However, the right is preferential, not absolute or automatic. If the company can prove that, since the employee’s re-entry request, no genuine vacancy has arisen in their group or professional category, it will not be breaching any obligation. The conflict arises when there have been vacancies and the company has preferred to fill them with third parties ignoring that right.

Conclusions: essential difference between job reservation and preferential right

The difference between the two cases is substantial. With job reservation (article 48.2 of the Workers’ Statute), the contract is suspended and the employee who improves within two years has the right to return to their own position, which the company must have kept for them. Without reservation, because the contract was terminated, the employee whose disability is revoked does not recover their position, but only a preference to fill the first vacancy in their group or category that arises in the company. In both cases, the disability is reviewable; what changes is the intensity of the labor protection accompanying that review.

For the company, the practical recommendation is twofold. First, carefully review the permanent disability resolution of each employee to verify if it contains the improvement provision of article 48.2 of the Workers’ Statute: if it does, the position must be reserved for two years and, if the disability is reviewed within that period, the employee must be reinstated. Second, when the contract has ended and the employee whose disability has been revoked applies to return, even if they do not express this entirely clearly, formally inform them of any vacancies in their group or professional category that exist or arise and, in parallel, seek proper advice. Proper treatment of either situation is fundamental.

Javier Marina Bartolomé